Visit us in Fayetteville for a free diamond appraisal today!
We are a family owned, 2nd generation jewelry store in Fayetteville NC. That means you can expect the highest payouts for your unwanted jewelry and diamonds! Our experts have served over 21,000 happy customers and counting.
Bring us your diamonds for a free appraisal and turn them into cash! Contact us today to get the best prices and personal service.

You could have valuable diamond jewelry tucked away in a box and not even know it! It can be hard to tell if you heirloom ring or gifted necklace is made with real diamonds. That's what were here for. Appraising and selling diamond jewelry can be a great way to give your items a new purpose while ensuring they are appreciated or repurposed by someone else.
Common examples of diamond jewelry we accept include:
Rings – Wedding bands, engagement rings, signet rings, or vintage cocktail rings
Necklaces & Chains – diamond encrusted chains, lockets, and pendants
Bracelets – Bangles, charm bracelets, and cuff bracelets
Earrings – Studs, hoops, chandelier earrings, or antique clip-ons
Watches – watch cases, bands, and vintage timepieces that feature diamonds
Brooches & Pins – Decorative pins and estate brooches
Scrap Diamonds & Broken Jewelry – Single earrings, tangled chains, loose gems or damaged pieces
If you’re considering selling your diamond jewelry, know that your pieces still have a story to tell—whether they find a new home or are transformed into something new. Selling your jewelry is a personal decision, and we believe in making the process as clear and respectful as possible.
If you have whole diamonds you'd like to sell, we're happy to do a free inspection and appraisal! We can let you know the value of your diamonds and walk you through your next steps. If you have diamonds that have fallen out of a jewelry setting, or you're looking to sell whole diamonds you've purchased, just stop in to our storefront. Our experts can give you the information you need to go forward in selling your pieces!

Bring your diamonds - no need to clean or prep them! Feel free to give us a call first if you have any questions.

Our jewelry experts have years of experience. When you bring in your items, you can trust we'll offer you the highest price - guaranteed.

If you choose to accept our offer, you'll walk away with a check in hand for the highest amount anyone would pay.

First, gather the items your curious about selling. Call us first if you have any questions. 2. Stop by our store for a free, no pressure, expert appraisal. 3. Walk away with a check in hand - confident you got the highest offer guaranteed!
Yes! We are experts on diamonds and can test and evaluate diamonds on site. Come to us first to make sure you're getting the best possible offer - or stop by for a second opinion if you've already had your diamond evaluated somewhere else.
Yes! We can boy individual coins or an entire collection. It's our goal to be the best coin buyer in Fayetteville. Give us a call or stop by today.
Our unique selection of antique & vintage jewelry is always changing. Stop in to see the latest handpicked selection!

Our goal is to be a welcoming source of knowledge. After 2 generations in the business, we've learned a lot! We give competitive offers for your coins based on expert appraisal methods. We'll never pressure you to sell or use any pushy tactics. We want your experience in the shop to be easy-going and positive, so we lead with transparency. Your questions will always be met with kindness and understanding. Stop in today for a free evaluation for your coins, and leave with the best offer available!
3710 Morganton Rd suite 100, Fayetteville NC 28303









HOURS:
Monday: Closed
Tuesday: 10am - 5pm
Wednesday: 10am - 5pm
Thursday: 10am - 5pm
Friday: 10am - 5pm
Saturday: Closed
Sunday: Closed

© Copyright 2026. Vintage Jewelry Company [North Carolina]. All Rights Reserved.