We Pay The Highest Price For Gold, Silver, & Platinum Guaranteed!

A Family-owned business in Fayetteville!

experienced coin buyers in FayettevillE, nc

Come by our store for a free evaluation!

Coin dealers in Fayetteville, NC

Expert Coin Buyers for Collections of All Sizes

Our jewelry shop does more than buy and sell unique vintage jewelry. We also buy and sell rare and collectable coins! We offer free appraisals for coin collections of all sizes.

We're a 2nd generation family owned and operated business, so we have the experience needed to give you a fair and competitive offer. We'll never pressure you to sell, and our goal is for you to leave with more knowledge about what you have (and hopefully more cash)!

Whether you're an experienced coin collector or you've inherited a collection you'd like to sell, we can help. Stop by for a free evaluation!

coin collecion in a coin storage book

how to sell your coins

Selling collectable coins

Coins can carry significant value based on their age, rarity, metal content, condition, and collector demand. Our team evaluates each piece carefully and explains what makes certain coins more desirable than others.

What Types of Coins Will We Buy?

Rare & Collector Coins

Rare coins are often valued for limited mintages, historical significance, unique errors, or strong collector demand. These can include older U.S. coins, key date coins, discontinued designs, and coins with unusual minting mistakes. Even if you’re unsure whether a coin is rare, it’s worth having it professionally evaluated.

Gold Coins

Gold coins are among the most sought-after items we buy because they carry both collector value and precious metal value. Common examples include American Eagles, Krugerrands, pre-1933 U.S. gold coins, and foreign gold coins from around the world. The value of gold coins can depend on rarity, condition, and current gold prices.

Silver Coins

Many older coins contain real silver and may be worth far more than their face value. U.S. dimes, quarters, and half dollars minted before 1965 are especially popular because of their silver content. We also buy silver dollars, commemorative coins, and silver bullion products.

Coin Collections & Inherited Collections

You don’t need to sort or organize a collection before bringing it in. We regularly help families who have inherited coin collections and aren’t sure where to start. Whether you have a small box of coins or an extensive collection gathered over decades, we can evaluate the contents and explain what you have in a clear, straightforward way.

Proof Sets & Mint Sets

Proof sets and mint sets are collections of coins produced by the U.S. Mint with special finishes or packaging. Some are highly collectible depending on the year, condition, silver content, and rarity. Keeping original packaging and certificates can sometimes add value.

Foreign Coins

Foreign coins can also hold collectible or precious metal value, especially older coins made from gold or silver. Certain international coins are highly desirable to collectors because of their history, artwork, or limited production numbers.

Selling Bullion Coins & Precious Metals

In addition to collectible coins, we also buy bullion products valued primarily for their precious metal content. This includes gold and silver rounds, bars, and investment-grade coins like American Eagles, Maple Leafs, and other popular bullion pieces.

HOW COIN BUYING WORKS

empty box with sparkles icon

BRING IN YOUR COINS

Bring your coins to our local Fayetteville shop. If you're not sure what you have and your coins are unsorted, no problem! We'll sort them for you during the appraisal step.

magnifying glass appraisal icon

GET A FREE COIN EVALUATION

Our team is a 2nd generation family of jewelry and coin buyers. We'll appraise your coins for free, and without pressure to sell. We'll happily answer any questions you have.

handshake with sparkles icon

RECEIVE AN OFFER

We'll explain what went into our appraisal process, and how we came to our offer. If you accept the offer, you'll leave with cash for your coins!

3710 Morganton Rd, Fayetteville, NC 28303, USA

come by for a free coin appraisal today

Our goal is to be a welcoming source of knowledge. After 2 generations in the business, we've learned a lot! We give competitive offers for your coins based on expert appraisal methods. We'll never pressure you to sell or use any pushy tactics. We want your experience in the shop to be easy-going and positive, so we lead with transparency. Your questions will always be met with kindness and understanding. Stop in today for a free evaluation for your coins, and leave with the best offer available!

3710 Morganton Rd suite 100, Fayetteville NC 28303

Best coin dealers in Fayetteville

See why our customers trust us to buy and sell coins and vintage jewelry.

Honest and Fair - I highly recommend!
No reason to be nervous here! From the moment you walk in, the folks there are super friendly and make you feel comfortable. They took the time to explain the process clearly, and I never felt pressured, which is always super appreciated! I ended up getting a much better price for my items than I expected, and the whole transaction was so quick and easy.
Soooo….if you're looking to sell coins, gold, silver, jewelry or anything else in Fayetteville, I can't recommend Vintage Jewelry enough! They're honest, trustworthy, and I'll definitely be back!!

Image

Nick B.

Great shop to buy silver bullion and silver coins! You can choose from a great selection of silver American eagles, silver bars or junk silver. Super helpful staff. You can also buy gold coins. Buy silver and gold and walk out the same day with it! Love it!

Image

Robin L.

Such a great experience. Very nice couple, took time with us and no pressure , free appraisal. Fair and honest. Got more than I expected. I went to 5 places and this was the best. I will go back. Recommend very highly!!

Image

Nancy H.

FAYETTEVILLE

(910) 634-6345

3710 Morganton Rd suite 100

Fayetteville 28303

Get Directions

3710 Morganton Rd, Fayetteville, NC 28303, USA

LOCATION

HOURS:

Monday: Closed
Tuesday: 10am - 5pm
Wednesday: 10am - 5pm
Thursday: 10am - 5pm
Friday: 10am - 5pm
Saturday: Closed
Sunday: Closed

© Copyright 2026. Vintage Jewelry Company [North Carolina]. All Rights Reserved.